A couple thoughts on the Catholic Church. As a married minister, I'm obviously not a huge fan of celibacy.
That said, the Catholic Church is free to make its own determination on this issue. Indeed, one thing that can be observed from the Randall Terry incident is that there is a lack of cross-denominational respect in America. Terry, rightly disciplined by his church in upstate New York, merely joined himself to the Charismatic Episcopal Church which welcomed him in with open arms despite his awful personal conduct.
I view the "ending celibacy requirement" as a simplistic solution to a much larger problem. The first question we must ask ourselves is, "Do we see this same rash of sexual abuse in the Catholic Church worldwide?" The answer is no. Then, if we don't see the same epidemic worldwide, the American Catholic Church's problem isn't celibacy rather it is a cultural problem.
We have seen a huge cultural decline and a growing coldness of many in the Catholic Church. Despite repeated admonitions from the pontiff, American Catholics continue to vote for politicians who are pro-abortion and disregard church teachings on numerous issues of morality. Nancy Pelosi, Edward Kennedy, and Joseph Biden can comfortably call themselves Catholics despite their far positions on the moral issues.
Catholics find themselves involved in a country that is filled with pornography and sexually explicit movies where the homosexual lifestyle is constantly pushed.
Will "ending celibacy" solve such a complex problem? No. We may have forgotten this but all pedophiles are not priests. Some are coaches, teachers, protestant ministers, and camp counsellers. Indeed, a primary reason for becoming involved in the priesthood for many pedophiles is the opportunity to get close to children.
The Catholic Church's problem is not that they have celibacy but that the church at the level of the pew from which every priest comes has suffered an ever-increasing corruption. It must solve its most dire moral problems and seek to revive its members from the point of spiritual death. I agree that Fabian Bruskewicz would be a good choice (isn't he the one who began excommunicating pro-aborts)?
